NY Times: Pedophilia, A Disorder, Not a Crime

The author, Margo Kaplan,an assistant professor at Rutgers School of Law

The author, Margo Kaplan,an assistant professor at Rutgers School of Law


NY Times: Think back to your first childhood crush. Maybe it was a classmate or a friend next door. Most likely, through school and into adulthood, your affections continued to focus on others in your approximate age group. But imagine if they did not.

By some estimates, 1 percent of the male population continues, long after puberty, to find themselves attracted to prepubescent children. These people are living with pedophilia, a sexual attraction to prepubescents that often constitutes a mental illness. Unfortunately, our laws are failing them and, consequently, ignoring opportunities to prevent child abuse.

The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders defines pedophilia as an intense and recurrent sexual interest in prepubescent children, and a disorder if it causes a person “marked distress or interpersonal difficulty” or if the person acts on his interests. Yet our laws ignore pedophilia until after the commission of a sexual offense, emphasizing punishment, not prevention.

Part of this failure stems from the misconception that pedophilia is the same as child molestation. One can live with pedophilia and not act on it. Sites like Virtuous Pedophiles provide support for pedophiles who do not molest children and believe that sex with children is wrong. It is not that these individuals are “inactive” or “nonpracticing” pedophiles, but rather that pedophilia is a status and not an act. In fact, research shows, about half of all child molesters are not sexually attracted to their victims.

A second misconception is that pedophilia is a choice. Recent research, while often limited to sex offenders — because of the stigma of pedophilia — suggests that the disorder may have neurological origins. Pedophilia could result from a failure in the brain to identify which environmental stimuli should provoke a sexual response. M.R.I.s of sex offenders with pedophilia show fewer of the neural pathways known as white matter in their brains. Men with pedophilia are three times more likely to be left-handed or ambidextrous, a finding that strongly suggests a neurological cause. Some findings also suggest that disturbances in neurodevelopment in utero or early childhood increase the risk of pedophilia. Studies have also shown that men with pedophilia have, on average, lower scores on tests of visual-spatial ability and verbal memory.

The Virtuous Pedophiles website is full of testimonials of people who vow never to touch a child and yet live in terror. They must hide their disorder from everyone they know — or risk losing educational and job opportunities, and face the prospect of harassment and even violence. Many feel isolated; some contemplate suicide. The psychologist Jesse Bering, author of “Perv: The Sexual Deviant in All of Us,” writes that people with pedophilia “aren’t living their lives in the closet; they’re eternally hunkered down in a panic room.”

While treatment cannot eliminate a pedophile’s sexual interests, a combination of cognitive-behavioral therapy and medication can help him to manage urges and avoid committing crimes. But the reason we don’t know enough about effective treatment is because research has usually been limited to those who have committed crimes.

Our current law is inconsistent and irrational. For example, federal law and 20 states allow courts to issue a civil order committing a sex offender, particularly one with a diagnosis of pedophilia, to a mental health facility immediately after the completion of his sentence — under standards that are much more lax than for ordinary “civil commitment” for people with mental illness. And yet, when it comes to public policies that might help people with pedophilia to come forward and seek treatment before they offend, the law omits pedophilia from protection.

The Americans With Disabilities Act of 1990 and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 prohibit discrimination against otherwise qualified individuals with mental disabilities, in areas such as employment, education and medical care. Congress, however, explicitly excluded pedophilia from protection under these two crucial laws.

It’s time to revisit these categorical exclusions. Without legal protection, a pedophile cannot risk seeking treatment or disclosing his status to anyone for support. He could lose his job, and future job prospects, if he is seen at a group-therapy session, asks for a reasonable accommodation to take medication or see a psychiatrist, or requests a limit in his interaction with children. Isolating individuals from appropriate employment and treatment only increases their risk of committing a crime.

There’s no question that the extension of civil rights protections to people with pedophilia must be weighed against the health and safety needs of others, especially kids. It stands to reason that a pedophile should not be hired as a grade-school teacher. But both the A.D.A. and the Rehabilitation Act contain exemptions for people who are “not otherwise qualified” for a job or who pose “a direct threat to the health and safety of others” that can’t be eliminated by a reasonable accommodation. (This is why employers don’t have to hire blind bus drivers or mentally unstable security guards.)

The direct-threat analysis rejects the idea that employers can rely on generalizations; they must assess the specific case and rely on evidence, not presuppositions. Those who worry that employers would be compelled to hire dangerous pedophiles should look to H.I.V. case law, where for years courts were highly conservative, erring on the side of finding a direct threat, even into the late 1990s, when medical authorities were in agreement that people with H.I.V. could work safely in, for example, food services.

Removing the pedophilia exclusion would not undermine criminal justice or its role in responding to child abuse. It would not make it easier, for example, for someone accused of child molestation to plead not guilty by reason of insanity.

A pedophile should be held responsible for his conduct — but not for the underlying attraction. Arguing for the rights of scorned and misunderstood groups is never popular, particularly when they are associated with real harm. But the fact that pedophilia is so despised is precisely why our responses to it, in criminal justice and mental health, have been so inconsistent and counterproductive. Acknowledging that pedophiles have a mental disorder, and removing the obstacles to their coming forward and seeking help, is not only the right thing to do, but it would also advance efforts to protect children from harm.

See also:

DCG

Please follow and like us:
error0
 

Leave a Reply

avatar
  Subscribe  
Notify of
MomofIV
Guest
MomofIV

This female clearly has screws loose in her white matter. It seems the next move for social deviants is a “coming out” party for pedophiles. If pedophilia is made into a legal disorder then pedophiles can basically get paid by the government (in terms of disability) to fantasize, molest, and rape children. These perverts who act out on children belong in jail, whether male or female. Her argument can also be made for rapists, maybe they should be in a mental institution or get disability checks because of their desire to rape. They have “marked distress or interpersonal difficulty” because… Read more »

Seumas
Guest
Seumas

Some people also propose “drawn” or “art” (commonly known as “loli” or “shota” respectively, at least in Japan.) as a victim-lss way of “treating” the problem, except that it doesn’t treat the problem, and anyone with any common sense should know that too… remember that native american proverb about the two wolves? This is a case of feeding the bad one again (it will not “treat” the problem, it will contribute to it, and induce criminal behavior, like with other unhealthy sicknesses cold turkey is the only route of any use, should serial killers be given a video game like… Read more »

surfercajun
Guest
surfercajun

all part of the all powerful new genie gig. I wonder how long will this be until taught in public schools?
Hey Mac, hand me a new shovel will ya?

Ralphy
Guest
Ralphy

it’s an easy fix. castrate them and the urge goes away.

truckjunkie
Guest
truckjunkie

Not sure that’ll do it,Ralphy. It could also cause them to get MORE violent,the rage and all.
I go more with re-opening and re-staffing the Mental Asylums that were closed,(due to cuts in budget and lawsuits to let people decide for themselves if they should be locked up) and re-admitting these lunatics that do harm to kids,as well as the nut-cases that have a tendency to go shoot large numbers of people then killing themselves to avoid prosecution.

Seumas
Guest
Seumas

The puppets of evil are seeing how fast they can get pedophilia legalized, after all homosexuality only took them how long? This will likely be in half the time, especially with things like omegle ensuring kids run into strangers looking to get off on them, sexting in schools due to those worthless wads of plastic they dare call phones, and the “sex ed” classes ensuring the children’s minds are warped as early as possible. the “disorder angle” is a canard and completely ignores the underlying causes (who suspects they’ll make “support foundations” to get cash reserves to help in legal… Read more »

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous

Progressive left/liberal normalizing of freakiness… for support. (Soviets used to just kill people like that after taking power, however.)

Ralphy
Guest
Ralphy

I don’t know truck….I remember neighbors cats getting “fixed” and their whaling stopped when in heat. Also per Wikipedia definition of castration
“This causes sterilization (i.e., prevents them from reproducing); it also greatly reduces the production of certain hormones, such as testosterone.”

Liz
Guest
Liz

Margo – you are a sick twist.

Steven Broiles
Member

The original phrase Eisenhower was supposed to have used was the “ACADEMIC-military-industrial complex,” but he was advised to drop the word “academic.” Regardless of the truth content of this article, Satan knows if he can ruin a person’s sexual function, he can move on to attack that person’s entire character and personality. The move to normalize or accept the homosexual orientation did not happen overnight, nor did the move to normalize or accept gay “marriage.” The move to normalize pedophilia has been going on for a few years now, and, like an insidious cancer, is not stopping. Our entire culture… Read more »

Dr. Eowyn
Admin

Actor Stephen Collins, who played the pastor-dad in the TV show 7th Heaven, must be thanking his lucky stars at this move to normalize pedophilia.
On Tuesday, news came that, in therapy sessions with his estranged wife Faye Grant, Collins had admitted to molesting or exposing himself to under aged girls. His admission is recorded on audio tapes.
https://pagesix.com/2014/10/07/inside-stephen-collins-sick-history-of-child-molestation/?_ga=1.111912260.1189178622.1397813656

MomofIV
Guest
MomofIV

Yeah, he’s disgusting. It makes sense though, because hollyweird only deals with their own degenerate kind (mostly). It makes sense they would hire their own kind to play the role of a Christian father and pastor because in reality he’s a pedophile. It’s their way of putting out a show that Christians like and at the same time laughing at us because the people who are supposed to represent our values are reprehensible and abominable. Oh, the irony! Just like all the other major roles of wholesome WASPs played on TV who are just a bunch of degenerates.

Ralphy
Guest
Ralphy

See that!! It can happen to anyone….it’s coming I’m afraid.