Facebook Suspends Evangelist Franklin Graham for his Biblical “Hate Speech”

3 (60%) 1 vote

Facebook’s “hate speech” suspension only lasted 24 hours. But it may have been the longest 24 hours yet for the social media giant. Evangelist Franklin Graham, CEO of the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association, told the Charlotte Observer that he was recently suspended from Facebook for taking a stand for his biblical beliefs. The offending “hate speech” that shut down Graham’s account was nothing recent. Rather it stemmed from an April 9, 2016 post in which Graham endorsed a North Carolina law that prevents men from being able to use women’s restrooms and locker rooms. In addition, Graham’s post urged a return to biblical principles as a way of life.

The Facebook suspension prompted an immediate flurry of comment from numerous media outlets, including Fox News, the Washington Post and The New York Times. In addition, the suspension was concurrent with a Times investigative report revealing that Facebook maintains a secret rule book for policing—and censoring—Facebook members’ speech.

Facebook moved quickly to remove the suspension, but not soon enough. By the time Facebook restored Graham’s account, the word was out. On December 28, Facebook apologized. A Facebook spokesperson admitted to the Charlotte Observer that Graham was indeed punished for his post. And while the spokesperson is now apologizing for censoring Graham, it’s clear that some of Facebook’s team of 15,000 speech police can censor conservative Christians at will.

Graham says it’s just wrong that his biblical comments would be ever considered “hate speech.”

“Facebook said the post went against their ‘community standards on hate speech.’ Facebook is trying to define truth. There was a character in a movie a few years back who said, ‘The truth is what I say it is!’ That’s what Facebook is trying to do. They’re making the rules and changing the rules,” Graham said.

But he says God’s truth will always be the only real truth. “Truth is truth,” Graham said. “God made the rules and His Word is truth. Actually, Facebook is censoring free speech. The free exchange of ideas is part of our country’s DNA.

Graham reposted his 2016 post, last week, asking readers to judge whether what he said was “hate speech.”

“April 9, 2016—Bruce Springsteen, a long-time gay rights activist, has cancelled his North Carolina concert. He says the NC law #HB2 to prevent men from being able to use women’s restrooms and locker rooms is going ‘backwards instead of forwards.’ Well, to be honest, we need to go back! Back to God. Back to respecting and honoring His commands. Back to common sense. Mr. Springsteen, a nation embracing sin and bowing at the feet of godless secularism and political correctness is not progress. I’m thankful North Carolina has a governor, Pat McCrory, and a lieutenant governor, Dan Forest, and legislators who put the safety of our women and children first! HB2 protects the safety and privacy of women and children and preserves the human rights of millions of faith-based citizens of this state.”

The suspension, however brief, raises serious questions. If Facebook is willing to block one of the most prominent Christian leaders in the world, then what’s next? Graham’s Facebook suspension also reinforces ongoing reports of censorship against Christian beliefs by other social media giants and the tech companies that control so much of the communication and interaction in our world today – companies such as Google, Twitter, WordPress and Apple.

The revelation that Facebook records, monitors, scrutinizes and judges all subscribers’ speech according to a draconian and biased set of secret rules is frightening. It is a direct threat to free expression and an assault on conservative and Christian values. Had Graham’s suspension been confined to his account, Facebook might have been able to say that it was a simple error in judgment. But it was not an aberration. It was a punitive suspension levied according to corporate policy that was, until then, a secret. But the cat, so to speak, is out of the bag.

Christopher Carbone, writing for Fox News, outlined the report by The New York Times that disclosed the existence of Facebook’s rulebook. He said the rulebook was Facebook’s attempt to eliminate misinformation and hate speech. But he noted that the effort was predicated on a “byzantine and secret document of rules packed with spreadsheets and power point slides that gets updated regularly for its global content moderators.”

He said the New York Times showed the social network to be “a far more powerful arbiter of global speech than has been publicly recognized or acknowledged by the company itself.” The Times, he said, discovered a range of gaps, biases and outright errors — including instances where Facebook allowed extremism to spread in some counties while censoring mainstream speech in others.”

The rulebook’s details were revealed by a Facebook employee who leaked more than 1,400 pages of the speech policing rulebook to the Times because he “feared that the company was exercising too much power, with too little oversight — and making too many mistakes.”

Carbone said that Facebook “is trying to monitor billions of posts per day in over 100 languages while parsing out the subtle nuances and complicated context of language, images and even emojis. The group of Facebook employees who meet every other Tuesday to update the rules, according to the Times, are trying to boil down highly complex issues into strict yes-or-no rules.”

Facebook, he said, then outsources the content moderation to other companies that tend to hire unskilled workers. The 7,500-plus moderators “have mere seconds to recall countless rules and apply them to the hundreds of posts that dash across their screens each day. When is a reference to “jihad,” for example, forbidden? When is a “crying laughter” emoji a warning sign?”

In the U.S., Facebook has banned the Proud Boys, a far-right group that has been accused of fomenting real-world violence. It also blocked an advertisement about the caravan of Central American illegal aliens put out by President Trump’s political team.

“It’s not our place to correct people’s speech, but we do want to enforce our community standards on our platform,” Sara Su, a senior engineer on the News Feed, told the Times. “When you’re in our community, we want to make sure that we’re balancing freedom of expression and safety.”

Monika Bickert, Facebook’s head of global policy management, said that the primary goal was to prevent harm, and that to a great extent, the company had been successful. But perfection, she said, is not possible.

“We have billions of posts every day, we’re identifying more and more potential violations using our technical systems,” Bickert told the newspaper. “At that scale, even if you’re 99 percent accurate, you’re going to have a lot of mistakes.”

Facebook’s most politically consequential and potentially divisive document could be an Excel spreadsheet that the Times reports lists every group and individual the company has barred as a “hate figure.” Moderators are told to remove any post praising, supporting or representing any of the people on that list.

Anton Shekhovtsov, an expert in far-right groups, told the publication he was “confused about the methodology.” The company bans an impressive array of American and British groups, he added, but relatively few in countries where the far right can be more violent, particularly Russia or Ukraine.

Still, there’s inconsistency in how Facebook applies the rules. In Germany, where speech in general is more scrutinized, Facebook reportedly blocks dozens of far-right groups. In nearby Austria, it only blocks one.

For a tech company to draw these lines is “extremely problematic,” Jonas Kaiser, a Harvard University expert on online extremism, told the Times. “It puts social networks in the position to make judgment calls that are traditionally the job of the courts.”

~ Grif

Rom 8: 38-39

Please follow and like us:

17 responses to “Facebook Suspends Evangelist Franklin Graham for his Biblical “Hate Speech”

  1. Conservatives & Christians, incl. Franklin Graham, should stop using Facebook. There are alternative social media:


    • They (and everyone else) should stop using censor happy google and youtube. There are many alternatives out there, boycott google, they suck.
      Vimeo is good, ditto duckduckgo.com and many other non google search engines. Facebook is a total sucky one of course, all they do is catalog info for the NSA.

  2. Delete Facebook. Imagine how many people would be deleting this useless social medium if all of Graham’s followers would hit that delete button. You have the power, people! Turn off those stupid tv shows. Don’t spend your money on mindless, violent or disgusting movies. Let the sponsors of these offensive media know why you are rejecting their products as long as they support filth and violence. The only thing these people care about is making a buck so hit them where it hurts…in their wallets. And take the time to let them know why you are rejecting them!!

    • Right. Watching TV news or listening to public radio is like smoking cigarettes, a bad habit that once broken reveals itself to have been a loathsome and disgusting vice all along.

      Once in a while I’ll put TV news on for a few minutes and it’s still shocking how madhouse-insane literally every aspect of it is. Richard Weaver pointed out 70 years ago the inherent propensity for evil in the format itself, where untold human suffering in foreign lands is offered up for dinnertime entertainment and then without apology immediately interrupted by the real business of enslaving Christian America to material gratification.

      On the sports front, an entire generation of men has been ironically formed into infantilized slugs by beer commercials, tits and ass they’ll never get within a hundred feet of and whose speech apes the jackass crackerbarrel commentary of morons who made millions running around in tights. These NFL fans are the televangelists’ easiest marks as well, sending bath tubs of money to a man like Reverend Hagee, who with a wife and kids at home was snorting his alleluias at the office between the legs of another woman. Or how about those paragons of Christian humility, the late Kenneth Copeland and Jesse Duplantis, who claim some deity they call gawd told them in person that even two private jets aren’t enough. As Brother Copeland put it—you can check out the video—gawd doesn’t want them flying in “these tubes filled with demons.” The thing is, the sophisticates laughing at the rubes sending those religious hucksters money are the bigger fools for ordering their worldview by what they see on TV news.

      A wormhole straight from hell couldn’t improve on this tool for destroying our nation, nor could there be a greater absurdity than claiming the Constitution guarantees some tiny group of American-hating aliens total control over a tool that literally shapes men’s minds.

      • Yep. It’s always full of lies spoken with breathless enthusiasm. It sounds like sports reporting. All of those talking heads hyping the day’s meme.

    • I junked my television 20 years ago. The last time I set foot in a cinema was 1980. If I feel the need to watch a film, I have many DVDs of great old movies made before Hollywood went into the toilet. Hard to believe a film like Song of Bernedette was even permitted to be made. I would not recognize a celebraty if they spit on my face. It’s amazing how one’s discernment grows when one Is not consuming entertainment filth.

      • We did the same thing pretty much. And it’s so nice! It de-stresses life somehow, not having the boob tube on and absorbing all the stress causing news.

  3. Facebook is the gossip way to let others know your business and how fast stupidity can travel.

  4. Thanks Grif. There’s no denying the fact that Facebook is at war with conservatives and Christians.

  5. Pat Condell on Leftist Big Tech:

  6. Who ya’ gonna believe, Sacred Scripture or (cough!), Marc Zuckerberg? There is a very old adage that Jews overreach. There is ample proof that its the truth. This is one of those examples.

  7. Yes. I spent a good deal of 2018 in FB jail, and now I’m in the middle of my FOURTH month-long stay for reacting to other peoples’ memes and calling people names!

    The Horror! The Horror!

    It’s a shame, because until last year, I took FB to be a great social media site, for two reasons. First, it’s visually appealing, and, Second, I’ve learned things I never would have found out otherwise. My FB friends were first to point out a number of other websites to me I never knew existed.

    I am on Gab now, but the visual appeal is lacking, I’m confined to 300 characters per post, and I don’t find that bonhomie I found on Facebook. I registered for MeWe, but I haven’t had the time to check them out.

    Maybe Facebook can find its Redemption once Lizard Boy fades away. He is but a sock puppet of George Soros, which means Soros himself has to fade away, too, but Lizard Boy is peculiarly repellent, in a league with David Hogg and Ben Shapiro!

  8. Truth is hate speech to those who hate the truth (aka Hatriots).

  9. What would anyone expect? The Israel Lobby is even rewriting textbooks, among many other rewrites “biblically” for the school kids that they’re chosen by god. They tend to forget their activism to separate Church & State. But that is the tribe, and chutzpa goes far far far far deeper than that https://www.israellobby.org/


Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.