Elites’ contempt for America’s white middle class

In early March 2016, three months before the last Republican Party primary elections that sealed Trump’s ascendancy as the party’s presidential nominee, Politico Magazine contributing editor Michael Lind called Trump “the Perfect Populist”—”one with broader appeal to the right and the center than his predecessors in recent American political history—so much so it could put him in the White House”.

Lind was unusual among pundits in predicting Trump’s electoral victory, as according to polling data he did not have even an outside chance of winning. What catapulted Trump to the White House, to the enduring shock and disbelief of the Democratic Party, was his message of what Victor Davis Hanson in his book The Case for Trump identified as “middle-class populism”—a populism of “less government, doubt over overseas military commitments, fears of redistribution and globalization, and distrust of cultural elites.” Their distrust, Hanson maintains, fundamentally was a reaction, not a catalyst, to the elites’ contempt for the white middle class:

[S]corn for the white middle class . . . was widespread among many elites, and it ignited a Trump backlash . . . . The anger that Trump tapped had been a long time in coming. But few politicians knew it firsthand, much less saw it as merited or even useful in the political sense . . . . [Trump] had seen a critical preexisting and vast swath of potential voters in proverbial swing states who were . . . resentful over the disdain shown them by elites, especially the likes of Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton. And they were irate at the winners of globalization who had somehow blamed them for being the global economy’s losers.

In other words, the elites’ contempt for the white middle and working classes predated the 2016 election.

Except in the cases of Obama and Hillary Clinton, the following account of contemptuous elites are from Hanson’s The Case for Trump.

To begin, eight years before the 2016 election, at a fundraising event in San Francisco on April 6, 2008, presidential hopeful Barack Obama condescendingly dismissed working-class voters in old industrial towns decimated by job losses as “bitter” people who “cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren’t like them or anti-immigrant sentiment or anti-trade sentiment as a way to explain their frustrations.”

For her part, at an LGBT fundraiser in Manhattan on September 9, 2016, Democrat presidential nominee Hillary Clinton urged supporters to “stage an intervention” if they had friends who might vote Trump. She then dissed millions of Americans over whom she intended to rule as president. Clinton said, “you could put half of Trump’s supporters into what I call the ‘basket of deplorables’. The racist, sexist, homophobic, xenophobic, Islamophobic — you name it.” After she lost the election to Trump and the “deplorables,” in a public speech in Mumbai, India on March 10, 2018, Clinton redoubled her contempt for Trump voters. She said, “So I won the places that are optimistic, diverse, dynamic, moving forward,” thereby implying that the 63 million Americans who had voted for Trump were demoralized, monotonous, listless, and degenerating.

Hillary Clinton’s aides were just as dismissive. In her book Chasing Hillary: Ten Years, Two Presidential Campaigns, and One Intact Glass Ceiling, New York Times reporter Amy Chozick described how Clinton’s inner circle looked down on Trump voters as fodder for their amusement: “The Deplorables always got a laugh, over living-room chats in the Hamptons, at dinner parties under the stars on Martha’s Vineyard, over passed hors d’oeuvres in Beverly Hills, and during sunset cocktails in Silicon Valley.”

Elites less prominent than Obama and Clinton similarly were contemptuous of Trump supporters. As examples, on August 12, 2016, FBI agent Peter Strzok texted to his paramour Lisa Page (both are married) that Trump voters stank: “Just went to a southern Virginia Walmart. I could SMELL the Trump support.” Another unidentified FBI employee texted an FBI attorney on the day after the 2016 election that “Trump’s supporters are all poor to middle class, uneducated, lazy POS [pieces of sh*t].”

In a tweet on January 7, 2017, Melinda Byerley, founder of the Silicon Valley company Timeshare CMO, wrote: “One thing middle America could do is to realize that no educated person wants to live in a sh**hole with stupid people. Especially violent, racist, and/or misogynistic ones . . . . When corporations think about where to locate call centers, factories, development centers, etc., they also have to deal with the fact that those towns have nothing going for them. No infrastructure, just a few bars and a terrible school system.”

Some members of the media were just as disdainful. In a tweet on August 2018, Politico reporter Marc Caputo mocked the crowd at a Trump rally as toothless hicks: “If you put everyone’s mouths together in this video, you’d get a full set of teeth.” Although Caputo initialy apologized for and deleted the tweet, he later doubled down, calling Trump supporters “garbage people.”

Another journalist, tech writer and member of the New York Times’s editorial board Sarah Jeong, a graduate of Harvard Law School who is of Korean heritage, tweeted: “Are white people genetically predisposed to burn faster in the sun, thus logically being only fit to live underground like groveling goblins?”; “Oh man it’s kind of sick how much joy I get out of being cruel to old white men”; and “White people marking up the internet with their opinions like dogs pissing on fire hydrants.”

Hillary Clinton wasn’t the only politician who regarded Trump voters with unconcealed contempt. On September 15, 2018, during a speech at the Human Rights Campaign’s annual dinner in Washington, D.C., former Vice President Joe Biden called the deplorables “virulent” “dregs of society”. He said: “Despite losing in the courts, and in the court of opinion, these forces of intolerance remain determined to undermine and roll back the progress you all have made. This time they—not you—have an ally in the White House. This time they have an ally. They’re a small percentage of the American people—virulent people, some of them the dregs of society.” Hanson points out that those “dregs of society” in 2016 numbered 63 million—46% of all Americans who voted.

Nor were Progressives the only elites who held the white middle and working classes in contempt. Republican “never Trumpers” were equally derisive.

In a March 2016 op-ed, National Review’s conservative social critic Kevin Williamson wrote: “The truth about these dysfunctional, downscale communities is that they deserve to die. Economically, they are negative assets. Morally, they are indefensible . . . . The white American underclass is in thrall to a vicious, selfish culture whose main products are misery and used heroin needles.”

On February 8, 2017, on a panel at the American Enterprise Institute, Bill Kristol, founder of the Weekly Standard, said white, working-class Americans should be replaced by immigrants. Kristol said:

“Look, to be totally honest, if things are so bad as you say with the white working class, don’t you want to get new Americans in? Basically if you are in free society, a capitalist society, after two, three, four generations of hard work, everyone becomes kind of decadent, lazy, spoiled, whatever. Then, luckily, you have these waves of people coming in from Italy, Ireland, Russia, and now Mexico, who really want to work hard and really want to succeed, and really want their kids to live better lives than them, and aren’t sort of clipping coupons or hoping that they can hang on and, meanwhile, grew up as spoiled kids and so forth.”

Another “never Trumper” conservative who became a self-described “man without a party” after the 2016 election, expressed the same wish. In a June 18, 2018 op-ed, Washington Post columnist Max Boot wrote: “If only we could keep the hard-working Latin American newcomers and deport the contemptible Republican cowards—that would truly enhance America’s greatness.”

For his part, New York Times conservative columnist David Brooks, with the ragged teeth, echoed the same sentiments in a January 29, 2018 op-ed: “These rural places are often 95 percent white . . . . They are often marked by economic stagnation, social isolation, family breakdown and high opioid addiction . . . . It is a blunt fact of life that, these days, immigrants show more of these virtues than the native-born.”

Hanson points out that these Progressive and conservative “never Trump” elites not only are racist, they are hypocrites. Conveniently, the elites excused their crude stereotyping of white, middle America by insisting that racism against whites was not racism. While accusing the middle and working classes they deride for “white privilege,” the elites are blind to their own outsized privileges. In Hanson’s words:

Often the white elite signaled their disgust of the ‘white privilege’ of the disintegrating middle class as a means of exempting their own quite genuine white privilege of insider contacts, professional degrees, wealth, inheritance, and influence.

I am baffled by why the elites hold such virulent hatred and contempt for America’s white middle and working classes who have built this country. It is a phenomenon for psychiatric professionals to explain. Alas, being of the same privileged professional elite class, they probably are infected with the same virus.

Perhaps our readers can hazard some guesses to explain this phenomenon.

~Eowyn

Drudge Report has gone to the dark side. Check out Whatfinger News, the Internet’s conservative frontpage founded by a military veteran!

Please follow and like us:
error0
 

16
Leave a Reply

avatar
11 Comment authors
MarkyMarkAuntie LuluLanaSplitfingerEdward smith Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
Notify of
Steven Broiles
Member

This is why I absolutely hate George H.W. Bush. An outdated WASP born with a silver spoon in his mouth, the man was Skull & Bones all the way: A sort of derivative Brit, he was polite on the surface and covertly racist and condescending to the “unwashed masses” that built this country. I could go on and on about the neo-con filth mentioned in this article (especially Kristol, the man with the permanent shit-eating grin etched on his face). But suffice it to say, these people—all of them—echo Bush the Elder’s contempt for humanity because they are REACTING to… Read more »

Splitfinger
Member
Splitfinger

DJT did more for the exposure of the Satanist cabal (Bush is 1 of many) than all of us have done since the emergence of Bill cooper. It will never be the same for them again if these criminals do not go to Jail at minimum then we will know what the next step will be …The rule of law is the only thing holding this together and if it no longer exists we are in for a ride… I believe that too much has been exposed that there is no turning back now the population has been enlightened by… Read more »

Auntie Lulu
Guest
Auntie Lulu

Steven . . . Bravo! Excellent contribution to this discussion. Thank you.

MarkyMark
Guest
MarkyMark

Remember how GHW Bush was astonished at the existence of talking cash registers? He had NO CLUE what they were, or that they existed! That one incident says it all AFAIAC about how out of touch the supposed ‘elites’ are with regular people…

Kelleigh
Guest
Kelleigh

Gads, all the neo-con-Trotskyites masquerading as something they aren’t and never will be. How ugly.

Kelleigh
Guest
Kelleigh

They hate white middle class because the majority of us love the founders of this country, white Europeans…and their goal is to destroy the Declaration of Independence (which mentions the creator who they also hate) and the Constitution which enumerates the freedoms and liberties given to mankind by God. Sadly the goal is control, the goal is globalism, and the goal is communism. None of these goals are compatible with America’s white middle class and their love of the roots of this once great country. Thus we must be denigrated and destroyed and they’ve been working on it for a… Read more »

SAF
Guest
SAF

Sad, true, and well said. “Having trivialized the past by equating it with outmoded . . . .fashions and attitudes, people today resent anyone who draws on the past in serious discussions of contemporary conditions or attempts to use the past as a standard by which to judge the present… A denial of the past, superficially progressive and optimistic, proves on closer scrutiny to embody the despair of a society that cannot face the future.” — Christopher Lasch, The Culture of Narcissism “A nation ignorant of its history is like a person with amnesia. Without a memory, the individual becomes,… Read more »

William
Member
William

The decimation of the nation’s industrial base and the resulting economic hopelessness are consequences of (anti-nationalist) globalization, offshoring of manufacturing jobs to low wage/ high repression countires, “free trade” agreements like GATT, NAFTA, etc. (they have aboslutely nothing to do with “free trade” in any meaningful sense), the resulting malaise, opiate addiction epidemic and so on – all the design of these same elites, to detroy the white middle class and bleed the country dry. They despise us for the simple reason that we are white and Christian and in the way of the grand design of their master, Satan.… Read more »

TrailDust
Admin

Yikes! We are hated!
But who cares? We will defeat them anyway because our Father owns this world, and will give us the advantage.

Alma
Guest
Alma

Do You want to know why the LOW LIFES WHITE Americans hate us? Because WE THE PEOPLE , THE WHITE -MIDDLE CLASS- Americans are above them. And they can’t stand it, it’s killing them!!!

Edward smith
Guest
Edward smith

The white, Christian middle class is derided by the elites because they never defend themselves. Attack Jews or blacks and see what happens.

Lana
Guest
Lana

Yes , but Whites are not allowed to defend themselves. Defending oneself and one race or heritage is now deemed White Supremacists. So they have established the narrative and Whites lose either way.

Lana
Guest
Lana

I think we can trace all of this back to the Kalergi Plan. This is Jewish hatred of a race they see as thwarting their plans for World domination. Yes we have plenty of White traitors who assist which are of two stripes; Freemasons, or the mentally ill Whites, the likes of which we see plenty of teaching at university. Let us go to basics….. No race, no peoples, no cultures have EVER been non traditional; i.e., not conservative. To be non traditional, that is to say, to reject the cultural foundations, and the love of ones own people equals… Read more »

William
Member
William

Psychiatric professionals by and large are mid-level members of the professional/managerial elite. Their purpose is to pathologize the masses and keep them confused and passive. A few honest ones have attempted to evaluate the elites psychologically and they invariably conclude that the elite-types, corporate CEO’s, politicians, ivory tower academics who churn out anti-Christian vitriol in their echo chamber think tanks, manifest all the traits of psychopathic personalities. And misanthropic in the extreme, they hate humans. Paradoxically, they also envy us. We’re still here and able to have lives of purpose and meaning despite their best efforts to destroy us. While… Read more »

William
Member
William

Don’t mean to pick on little mzzz Sarah Jeong but I must say her face is eminently punchable. Since that would be dishonorable I’d love instead to engage her in lively debate. By the time I was finished she’d be curled up in a fetal position under her Smart Desk. I assume it is, she being a “tech-writer” and all. I suspect she would survive all of thirty seconds in the real world. Her whole presentation screams “self”, with a mile-wide mean streak. By the way, the day-glo hair I’ve noticed is a fashion favored by device-addicted lardbags in Wal-mart.… Read more »

Auntie Lulu
Guest
Auntie Lulu

Dr Eowyn . . . Thank you for this excellent article. It is inconceivable to me that individuals who are also white, feel such hatred for other white working, or middle class people. Just like other bullies, in their own minds they elevate themselves when they put others down.