Bedtime reading could disadvantage other children, academic says

bedtime story
9News.com: Could snuggling up in bed and reading a bedtime story to your children ever be a bad thing?

An ABC Radio National program about whether “Having a loving family is an unfair advantage” has questioned whether bedtime reading is causing an uneven playing field for more unfortunate children.
Adam Swift

Adam Swift

British academic Adam Swift told ABC presenter Joe Gelonesi the benefits of the time-honoured custom were greater than a private school education.
“Evidence shows that the difference between those who get bedtime stories and those who don’t — the difference in their life chances — is bigger than the difference between those who get elite private schooling and those that don’t,” Mr. Swift said.
According to Mr. Swift, the “devilish twist” was whether bedtime stories should be restricted.
are you serious
Ultimately the net good of bedtime reading in promoting strong family bonds outweighed any other downsides, Mr. Swift said.
“You have to allow parents to engage in bedtime stories activities, in fact we encourage them because those are the kinds of interactions between parents and children that do indeed foster and produce these (desired) familial relationship goods.”
But parents should be mindful of the advantage provided by bedtime reading, he said. “I don’t think parents reading their children bedtime stories should constantly have in their minds the way that they are unfairly disadvantaging other people’s children, but I think they should have that thought occasionally,” he said.
Mr. Swift told the Daily Telegraph the idea of evening the playing field by encouraging all parents to read to their kids was not discussed. The bedtime stories idea had been suggested by the ABC “as a way of getting attention”, he said.
Professor Frank Oberklaid, from the Murdoch Childrens Research Institute, told the newspaper he was “bewildered” by the idea of bedtime reading disadvantaging others. “It’s one of the more bizarre things I’ve heard,” he said. “We should be bringing all kids up to the next level.”
DCG
Please follow and like us:

Share and Enjoy !

0Shares
0 0 0
 
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Glenn47
Glenn47
5 years ago

Disadvantaged for Whom? We always read to the children and books have always been a large part of our lives. I’ll be danged if I dumb down my family because this over educated hypocritical moron thinks it is disadvantaged for some. The poorest person in the world can go to the library and get a book for free and start sharing and educating their children. It doesn’t take long.
Just another liberal smuck trying to help dumb down the children. You do not have to go to a private school to enjoy reading.
Glad I wasn’t one of his kids.

Dr. Eowyn
Admin
Dr. Eowyn
5 years ago

To Adam Swift:
Since you are a “British academic” and, from your pic, a white male, clearly you yourself are the recipient of countless “unfair advantages.” I suggest you resign from your university position, and surrender all your money and possessions to the government for “re-distribution” to the “disadvantaged.”

PatriotUSA
5 years ago
Reply to  Dr. Eowyn

And Adam Swift should eliminate himself from using up anymore of our precious resources to even better enrich those who are so starved of cultural enrichment. What a complete wanker.

Glenn47
Glenn47
5 years ago
Reply to  PatriotUSA

Precious resources, like Oxygen?

TrailDust
Admin
TrailDust
5 years ago

Another Harvard educated fool.

Lance Jackson
Lance Jackson
5 years ago

When I was a wee lad, long before the days of affirmative black racism, mom read to me at bedtime and took me to the library with her. She fostered in a love of reading and learning. I suppose in today’s world that is considered white privilege and must be stopped while little cca children are out looting, burning knockout gaming and and raping which is a healthy all African/Hispanic pastime, reading to children must be banned <said in utmost sarcasm

japoa
5 years ago

I think this man qualifies for a ” Special kind of stoooopid ” award . I’m sure he would be in favor of a D.F.A.C.S. worker doing the reading / propagandizing to the child though !

Mike howrightismike
Mike howrightismike
5 years ago
Reply to  japoa

Ha ha! How about our useful idiot of the month award?

japoa
5 years ago

Works for me ……….I would hate to be his child

dee
dee
5 years ago

WOW! WOW! i can’t even form a sentence here. WOW!

BobToonist
BobToonist
5 years ago

Seems to me….. and I don’t want to get off on a rant here….. If more ‘parents’ would spend some time with their kids, reading to them or just letting them know that they have a supportive family….. … and kids would develop a greater interest in reading, and not texting, or tweeting, or just ‘facebooking’…. … and kids would develop better speech patterns and learn to dress properly indicating that they have self respect and respect for others. … then there might be higher graduation rates, higher SAT scores, ‘graduates’ better able to contribute to the betterment of society…… Read more »

evh
evh
5 years ago

My bedtime reading as a child and as a young girl are among my most treasured memories. Without them I wouldn’t be the person I am today. How can I ever forget The Prince and The Pauper, by Mark Twain, read to me as only my mother could read it? Or The Girl of the LImberlost, a gift from my grandmother? Or The Song of Bernadette, a gift from a very dear friend? As a young girl, I remember being curled up in bed on winter evenings reading Lorna Doone and falling asleep wishing I had a lover like John… Read more »

PatriotUSA
5 years ago

This is as STOOPID as progressives whining that using white paper in schools is racist.

Auntie Lulu
Auntie Lulu
5 years ago

Wow! Just imagine . . . life just isn’t fair! The sad thing is that some kids got sent to the homes of lazy, shiftless parent(s) who just can’t be bothered to read to their kids. To heck with the unfairness of it all–keep on readin’ to your child, and let other children’s parent(s) do what they will. They are the ones who are guilty of neglecting their offspring. For this gentleman to suggest otherwise is absurd, and in fact I believe that he is a nincompoop!

Glenn47
Glenn47
5 years ago

Another thing I always did with my children was sitting down and coloring, lots and lots of coloring books. You can open their minds while engaging them in conversation. It is amazing what you can find in those little minds.
It was time well spent

Steven Broiles
5 years ago

This is the politics of envy, and after having studied the flow of ideas on the internet for over six years now, many of the bad ideas that have infected society have come out of England. Let me see if I have this straight: In order for you not to feel “uncomfortable” I am obligated to stay put while you not only fail to get ahead, but drag me down with you? ARE YOU INSANE, OR ARE YOU JUST PLAIN EVIL? THIS is what Daniel Patrick Moynihan meant when he wrote “Defining Deviancy Down.” THIS is Gresham’s Law applied to… Read more »

Anonymous
Anonymous
5 years ago
Reply to  Steven Broiles

Kurt Vonnegut’s short story “Harrison Bergeron”…
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrison_Bergeron

slackwaterbloop
5 years ago

This is disgraceful weak thinking. By this reasoning, it must be equally true that those parents who don’t take the trouble to read and interact with their own children are creating an uneven playing field, putting their children at a disadvantage. However some of those parents may also be creating another uneven/advantageous ‘playing field’ (is education a competitive sport?) by teaching their children to dance, sing, catch a ball, jump a ditch, bring in a fish, ride a horse, share their lunch with a friend who forgot his, and these achievements may also involve family bonding and feelings of love.… Read more »

slackwaterbloop
5 years ago
Reply to  DCG

Based on that kind of thinking, anything you teach your children, any skill they are allowed to develop, could be seen as giving them an unfair advantage, even walking – after all there are children who cannot walk. Must everything be reduced to some lowest, common to all, denominator? This is not, in my opinion a path to fairness in life. To teach all children to think critically, to spot injustice, to see when freedom is being hi-jacked and to notice when we are being misled, these are more likely to lead to fairness. We each have talents and they… Read more »

slackwaterbloop
5 years ago
Reply to  DCG

The ‘Utopia’ of Mediocrity, where nobody is encouraged to blossom, and any blossoms that appear are stamped out. Descent into misery, no celebration of talent or skill, no painters unless they scramble their colours to brown.

Harry B
5 years ago

Anyone who would like the true story behind this imaginative invention, you can read it here:
https://crookedtimber.org/2015/05/11/rush-limbaugh-and-bedtime-stories-definitely-not-the-worst-thing-that-happened-last-week/