Harvard’s minimum wage protests were caused by its own professors

liberal logis

Via NY Post: The social-justice warriors of Harvard are on the march again, this time in solidarity with the university’s dining-hall workers. Students and faculty have spent the past few days protesting low wages and an increase in health-care premiums for the people serving their grilled cheese, french fries and occasional lobster dinners.

On Oct. 5, about 750 workers went on strike. It was Harvard’s first such revolt in 33 years, and strikes are becoming more common at colleges across the country. In Pennsylvania, thousands of faculty went on strike at 14 colleges and universities on Wednesday alone.

Harvard was fortunately prepared, having stocked up on frozen food for students in the days leading up to the walkout. But who knows when their TV dinners will run out. Two weeks later, things seem to have reached an impasse. Harvard has closed six of its 14 dining halls, staffing its remaining ones with temporary workers and giving students money to spend at local pizza joints.

In its defense, Harvard says, the dining-hall workers make an average of almost $22 per hour, more than the $15 living wage required by the People’s Republic of Cambridge. Moreover, the university says that health-care costs are going up all over the country and dining-hall workers are going to have to bear some of the brunt of that.

The Chronicle of Higher Education sums up Harvard’s problem pretty well. “How does the richest university in the world negotiate with some of its lowest-paid workers?” the publication asks. When your endowment is over $37 billion, why don’t you pay the people who serve food more than $30,000 per year?

harvard-strike

The argument seems to be carrying weight. Earlier this week, Harvard divinity students wore yellow flowers in their hair and sang “Lean On Me” and “We Shall Overcome” as they protested outside the Science Center. They ate bread together, which, according to divinity student Nestor J. Pimienta “symbolized that we’re sharing in the struggle.”

It’s always fun to share in the struggle when you get to skip out on class. According to an account in the Crimson, “After chants of ‘No justice, no peace!’ subsided, [professor] Timothy P. McCarthy ascended the steps of University Hall to address the crowd, which had reached hundreds of people. McCarthy announced to cheers that he had ‘cut short’ his lecture in ‘American Protest Literature from Tom Paine to Tupac’ to walk out with his students.”

Harvard’s undergraduates clearly see the plight of its dining-hall workers as the latest story of oppression in American history. But they seem not to see that Harvard professors actually support the very policies that have put the university in this bind.

In 2014, 10 Harvard scholars sent a letter to Congress insisting that an increase in the minimum wage would not negatively affect employment rates. Indeed, former Harvard Law professor and current Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren has testified before Congress in favor of a $22 minimum wage.

elizabeth_warren

The assumption of these liberal scholars is that the rich who run corporations (or “nonprofit” institutions in this case) are simply hoarding money. If we want the poor to get more money, employers of these workers should just pay them more. And if they don’t, we should get the government to mandate that they do.

Who cares if you’re paying more than minimum wage? If you have more money, fork it over. Why shouldn’t dining-hall workers make as much as English professors? The laws of supply and demand simply don’t enter into the thinking of pointy-headed students and faculty.

The real sticking point in negotiations with the dining-hall workers is rising health insurance premiums. The cost of health insurance has gone up somewhere around 20% nationwide because of the Affordable Care Act. Insurance companies are canceling plans left and right, and the pool of insured people are older and less healthy than forecasters projected — meaning that it’s going to get worse.

As a 2015 article in the National Interest pointed out, “the Harvard faculty is chock-a-block with ObamaCare’s biggest boosters. The new plan was approved by Harvard’s provost, the economist Alan M. Garber, who had signed on to a 2009 open letter assuring the president that a tax on high-end insurance plans “offers the most promising approach to reducing private-sector health-care costs while also giving a much needed raise to the tens of millions of Americans who receive insurance through their employers.”

The Harvard faculty screamed bloody murder last year when the administration tried to raise their health-insurance premiums. Obviously, their dining-hall workers are less able to absorb these increases. But the policies pushed in Harvard’s faculty lounges have left everyone — not just the students eating ramen noodles — much worse off.

DCG

7 responses to “Harvard’s minimum wage protests were caused by its own professors

  1. “In its defense, Harvard says, the dining-hall workers make an average of almost $22 per hour”
    a job that requires no real experience except being alive pays $22/hr to start and these idiots are complaining?
    $15/hr isn’t even enough….as for warren (faux-cahontas) maybe she and her ilk can pay for the $22/hr hike from their own paychecks.
    when are these liberals going to realize all that extra money has to come from somewhere and it’s not from the politicians. I guess as long as they get theirs that’s all that matters…that type of mentality today is part of the reason this country is so messed up…when people with no common sense are given control over lawmaking and other people’s lives everything falls apart….because the dumb are leading the dumb.

    Liked by 3 people

  2. Since when are the job skills required by food service workers worth in excess of $30,000 a year? I am sick and tired of all these agitators. Just replace these lamo workers with people who want a job and are willing to work.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. $22 an hour. Highly skilled and experienced American medical transcriptionists in the US are now being paid 4 cents a line to redo our own (all of us, yours, mine; everybody’s) US medical records after they are first shipped all over India to let 4 or 5 different English second language “typists” have a crack at each one, before sending them back in bizarre condition…to be cleaned up by US MTs. Four cents a line translates to anywhere from less than $5 an hour to an upper range of $12 to $15 IF the audio and dictation are extremely good (rare). No matter whether an MT makes $5 or $15 in a given hour, their time is spent at a breakneck pace with no food or rest breaks, no paid time off, no vacations (with the exception of very rare decent employers), always working weekends and holidays (no extra compensation for that). The majority have to work nights because it’s more convenient for India. Because MTs have been railroaded into virtually all working at home, they have become horribly exploited slaves who cannot even bring class-action lawsuits because a judge apparently decided that working at home makes “each situation different,” even though the job and conditions are exactly the same. So, again, food servers complaining about $22/hr. Really????

    Incidentally, medical transcriptionists have been screaming all of this from the rooftops for years (in particular the patient safety and HIPAA violation aspects). They’ve written to and called every possible politician, activist, forum, and oversight organization, repeatedly. Crickets. An entire medical profession is being looted and our critical health records being beyond recklessly mishandled, and nobody cares?

    Sorry, can’t read a story like this without being just amazed that skilled medical professionals are losing their homes and living in poverty while this goes on.

    Liked by 3 people

  4. I knew immediately that Obozo Care was a farce, when I discovered that there was no discount for those who could prove a healthy lifestyle. That meant just one thing, that Obozo Care was nothing but a way to keep the Pharmaceutical Corporations afloat on inflated medication costs. A medication for every disease you have, so treatment for a lifetime! Eighty percent of the population are on at least one! My most interesting patient was on 19 of them, he came to see me because he was afraid he would not live to see his son graduate from high school.

    Yes, they are afraid of a large identifiable healthy class, it would totally sink that bloated farce of a medical system! A healthy class of people would show-up via diet, cleansing, exercise, avoiding stress, and seeking Spiritually! Once started a healthy class like that would upset the drugs for symptoms driven medicine, and start to reveal its weaknesses. Plus nothing like large studies of healthy class of people who don’t ever get sick, e-v-e-r!

    That is what I found, at 72 years old, with a genetically weak prostate, lungs, and low back…I cleared my prostate of cancer through Cleansing and Detoxing 30 years ago…that was the last time I was sick…My back is a mess, but I treat it well so it never bothers me. And I keep my lungs also clear using mostly the right foods, and a Cleansing program that lasts one 24 hr day a week. Plus, week long Cleanses, and Detoxes four times a year, so I am on zero drugs, and healthy as a horse!
    —Road race bicycle 4 days a week, weight training 5 days, heavy and speed bag training every day because I love it. Yoga stretches, and power breath training every day. Results, I am stronger in my 70’s than I was in my 40’s…
    —So why would I want to pay into Obozo Care, for someone who treats them-self like garbage, and takes poisonous drugs to continue living that way? Screw them, I want to keep my money, and I don’t want their MD’s, and their crap medicines, or toxic vaccines anywhere near me!

    Liked by 2 people

  5. My proposal to the oh-so-caring and very well-paid (in 3 figures) Harvard faculty: How about you share some of your earnings with those poor $22/hr. minimum-wage (!) dining-hall workers?

    [Sound of crickets]

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: Harvard’s minimum wage protests were caused by its own professors — Fellowship of the Mindsc | kommonsentsjane

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s